Messy Rambling Thoughts on the Huntresses: There Can Be Only One (No, It Doesn’t’)

Recently, DC has announced that Helena Bertinelli will return as Dick Grayon’s partner in the Grayson series and will be reinvented as a spy. The writer has tweeted that they have found a way to maintain the soul of the character while still doing something news. Perhaps not coincidentally, the promo pics for Futures End shows a dead Helena Wayne in Earth 2 Batman’s arms while Kara is stricken with grief while Val holds her close to comfort her.

Now much of the debate about Helena Bertinelli has centered on what constitutes a character. DC has established this trend of rewriting established characters to the point where they are completely unrecognizable. Looking at what they have done with characters like Tim Drake, Bart Allen (or Bar-Tor?), Superboy and various other characters, Bertinelli fans of course have a right to be paranoid.

However, with all this discussion about what makes a character and dark and edgier reboots, I can’t help but think back to the late 80’s after the Crisis on Infinite Earths had thoroughly destroyed the Multiverse and the Earth 2 characters were moved to one singular earth with their histories completely re-written. Previously, there were two Huntresses: one was the daughter of Batman and Catwoman who lived on Earth 2 and succeeded them as protectors of Gotham and there was the villainess Huntress who was married to Sportsmaster and dressed in a tiger outfit. The latter is irrelevant to this discussion.

Once upon a time there was Huntress, Helena Wayne, daughter of Batman and Catwoman who is a crime fighter and had a good relationship with her parents before they died. She fought with a crossbow, was a detective and had a strong friendship with Powergirl. Then came the Crisis which wiped away that Huntress and in her place stood the daughter of a dead mafia boss who had a bad temper, had no problem killing people if necessary, was self-destructive before meeting Oracle, had a bad relationship with Batman (much of it being manufactured for the sake of drama) and virtually no relationship with Catwoman. Gone was the friendship with Powergirl and the new Huntress was firmly established as the red headed step child of the Bat Family. The Huntress was now renamed as Helena Bertinelli. As it turns out that Helena Bertinelli is also a gritty reboot of an existing superhero.



Furthermore, much like how the Crisis would unceremoniously dump Helena Wayne in favor of Bertinelli, the New 52 would also kill off Bertinelli off screen in order to bring back Wayne. That is until now where it looks like Helena Wayne is going to be killed off to make way for Bertinelli…..again.

I freely admit that I prefer Helena Wayne, the 70’s Wayne not the New 52 version, over Bertinelli. However, this constant need to sacrifice one version of the character for the other to exist is tiring. I want people to like Helena Wayne and to give her chance and maybe get some good writing under her belt but how can I expect to get people to like her when DC has to dump on one set of fans in order to placate to the other?

Why can’t we have two Huntresses? After all, Bertinelli and Wayne have worn vastly different costumes and have very different histories. It’s not like DC has had multiple characters using the same code names: we have had two Flashes, two pairs of Hawks, more Starman’s than you can count with two hands and multiple Sandman’s. So really? What is the excuse? You can’t say that the fans would be confused, that’s an insult to their intelligence and it’s not like they don’t have access to a network of free flowing information to help clear up any doubts or anything, or that good writers and editors will make sure not to have new readers confused or that DC for a long time has been catering more towards people who are already familiar with comics and buying them for decades instead of branching out to new readers.

Basically, DC, this is not Highlander starring the Huntress where ‘there can be only one’. There doesn’t have to be one ‘true Huntress’, you can make way for both of them. What happened to the days when we had two Flashes, 3 Hourmen and when Ollie Queen and Connor Hawke were both Green Arrow’s who can operate side by side?

As for reboots: they are almost always messy. DC was cleaning up the mess from the original 1985 COIE all the way till 2005’s Infinite Crisis. I have no problem with altering a character so long as it makes for a good story and makes sense for their character. Helena Bertinelli spent a few years working with Oracle so there is a precedent for her working as a spy. As I said in one discussion, Bertinelli might end up being the ‘Black Widow’ to Dick Grayons’s ‘Steve Rogers’.

Moreover, sometimes rewriting characters tend to work out for the best; the JLU version of John Stewart, Hawkgirl and Wally West were very different from their comic book versions. Their histories and personalities were re-written for the show but more than few people have said that they prefer those versions of the characters over the comic book ones. After the Crisis, Black Canary (Dinah Laurel Lance) had her origin rewritten and Secret Origins #50 from 1986 stands as one of the best and most powerful superhero origins I’ve read.

Other times, rewrites just don’t work out. For example, see the JLU version of Wonder Woman and Cheetah as well as the New 52 and YJ versions of Zatanna. Also, the aforementioned ‘Bar-Tor’ and Tim Drake.

It’s unknown which side the new Helena Bertinelli will fall under and there is bound to be many schools of thought regarding this. I just thought that I would throw in my two cents.



Posted in Uncategorized | Tagged , , , , | Leave a comment

New Thoughts On David Bowie’s ‘Valentine’s Day’.

Remember that little post I did about Bowie’s song called ‘Valentines Day’ a while back?

Well, my opinion on it has changed after having to digest and really give the song a good listen. It is indeed and undeniably about a shooter. I feel a little silly for having thought differently and going in half cocked with my own interpretation before actually giving it a good look. It’s a brilliant song with lots of chilling subtle images with the guitar serving as a gun and the subject about a shooter explains more about Bowie’s manic expressions than my own idea of it being about the hopes and dreams of a kid.  While I am glad that my opinions can and do change, I’ll file this under my ‘look before you talk’ folder.

Also, hey! It’s been a while.  Life caught up with me and I had to get some stuff in order. The dearth of topics to talk about certainly kept me from posting but once again, I am back because I have something to say again.  

Posted in Uncategorized | Tagged , | Leave a comment

Theory on xxxholic Rei

So xxxholic Rei 11 came out and I am convinced that the Yuuko we saw in the chapter or possibly even all the chapters so far is in fact an evil alternate version of her from Earth 3!

Why do I say this? Because of her dress in the latest chapter:

Look at that: the flame themes, the eeeeevil torn bits of dress, the weird stare she gives Watanuki throughout the chapter, the cleavage! Wait, she does that anyway, never mind.
Continue reading

Posted in Uncategorized | Tagged , | Leave a comment

You May Think That I Don’t Believe In Miracles….

That I don’t believe in anything amazing because I am an atheist. That I live in damp, dark and literal world.  

You couldn’t be more wrong.  


The fact that we are here, just us, on this little rock circling around the sun constantly searching for answers, constantly discovering something new and that we came from random chemical reactions and meteor bombardments is a big enough miracle for me.  

There is so much left to learn, discover and experience in the world, why would you limit yourself in anyway?  

Posted in Uncategorized | Tagged | Leave a comment


Never before has a song touched me and moved me so deeply. Sometimes it’s as though everything I do is an effort to ignore the pain.  It’s like a stake wedged in your heart that just can’t be removed. 

Posted in Uncategorized | Tagged , | Leave a comment

Naruto: Road to Ninja

To love Naruto is to know frustration and disappointment. 

I will always have a soft spot for this manga. It was my gateway into the manga world, prior to that I only watched anime like Pokemon (up to Johto League),  Digimon, etc, etc. Naruto was what got me started on manga and paved the way for a lot of awesome stories I read, ranging from One Piece to Fullmetal Alchemist to Shin Angyo Onshi and various other manga’s and a few manhwa’s.  Plus a wonderful group of online friends who have taught me so much.   

Continue reading

Posted in Uncategorized | Tagged , | Leave a comment

The Message In All Of Bowie’s Songs

Well, it turns out that ‘Valentines Day’ was about a shooter.  Normally, I would take this as someone’s interpretation of the song but Tony Visconti confirms that it is indeed about a shooter and Bowie is wondering about the mindset of the shooter.

I am still trying to digest this bit of information but my current reaction is to deny it.    Continue reading

Posted in Uncategorized | Tagged , | 1 Comment